When Jason Wilcox joined Manchester United in April of 2024, there was a murmuring of hope escaping the lips of those in Manchester, hoping this could be the final cog in the machine that would push United back into their glory days.
Instead, the two and a half years since his appointment have been some of the dreariest days in the club's history, with things seemingly lurching to a new low every week.
In a report written by Laurie Whitwell, Jacob Tanswell, and Mario Cortegana of The Athletic, they outlined the specific factors that have led to Wilcox coming under increasing scrutiny.
Initially arriving at Old Trafford as technical director in April 2024, with the intention of working under incoming sporting director Dan Ashworth. However, following Ashworth’s departure in December, Wilcox moved into the role of sporting director, before being promoted to director of football in June of 2025.
His influence over United's managerial appointments has also been significant. He played a role in the search for Erik ten Hag's successor, with his admiration for possession-based football helping shape the type of manager he favoured.
One particular revealing detail that came from The Athletic’s reporting was Wilcox’s admiration for then Southampton manager Russell Martin.
Wilcox was seemingly aware that despite his admiration for his former colleague, his inexperience at the highest level made him unsuitable for the job. Wilcox viewed him as an option for the future.
Martin's promotion campaign with Southampton was impressive, guiding the club back into the Premier League through the play-offs and overseeing a 25-match unbeaten run. However, his subsequent spell in the top flight exposed the limitations of his approach, with an unwavering commitment to playing out from the back repeatedly leaving his side vulnerable.
His Southampton side would collect just five points from their opening 16 games before he was eventually dismissed at the start of December following a humiliating 5-0 home loss to Tottenham Hotspur.
There is nothing inherently wrong with Wilcox favouring possession-based football. However, Martin's managerial record raises questions about the importance he places on a particular philosophy over the ability to adapt and deliver results.
This has not been the only concern directed at Wilcox this year, with recruitment also being a major concern.
Wilcox has overseen eight senior arrivals in his time leading United's football operation, including Matheus Cunha, Bryan Mbeumo, Benjamin Sesko and Senne Lammens. The latter has arguably been the most encouraging addition, while Cunha and Mbeumo have shown their quality. Nevertheless, questions remain over whether the overall investment has delivered the improvement required.
This summer, however, business has attracted particular criticism. Wilcox spearheaded the arrivals of Andrey Santos, Youri Tielemans, Karl Darlow, and Carlos Baleba, with the decision to focus entirely on the midfield, neglecting the weak full-back and striker positions.
These weaknesses have now been exposed, with Luke Shaw and Patrick Dorgu both out of contention due to injuries, while Sesko is expected to be out until the new year.
Those frustrations came into the public domain following United's Champions League defeat to Atletico Madrid in October. Lisandro Martinez was particularly outspoken, insisting: "I expect more from our technical director [Jason Wilcox]."
Further revelations about Wilcox's decision-making are unlikely to reassure an already frustrated fanbase, particularly with Michael Carrick seemingly balancing on a knife edge as pressure continues to mount.
Add us as a preferred source on Google